• RSS


The experts weigh in on the pluses and minuses of potential Islander picks

Wednesday, 06.23.2010 / 11:33 PM ET / News
By Tom Liodice
Share with your Friends

Mock drafts are all the rage this time of year.

Experts around the hockey world, scouts, and teams stir up conversation on whether or not a certain player should be ranked higher than the other, or if this goalie is better than that goalie.

Now it's no secret that the perennial 1-2 combination with most likely consist of Taylor Hall and Tyler Seguin in some order. So we checked in with NHL Director of Central Scouting E.J. McGuire to find out a little more about the No. 3-5 ranked North American skaters in the Draft: Erik Gudbranson, Cam Fowler, and Brandon Gormley.

On Gudbranson: "(He's) more of an NHL all-around defenseman with size, speed, skill and meanness. He has got a meanness that would remind one of Dion Phaneuf or Chris Pronger. High, yet unrealized potential."

On Fowler: "He's more of a niche player in an offensive contributor category. He was a key cog in quarterbacking the Windsor Spitfires Memorial Cup championship team on the power play. A lot of his shots didn't get through to the net in a goals point of view (8 G, 55 GP). But he sure made up for that in vision with 45 assists in 55 games is pretty darn impressive. He will be ready to step into the National Hockey League as a power play contributor next year. On a projection point of view, there's reason to believe to be a Jack Johnson or Erik Johnson point of view."

On Gormley: "Confidence and poise. Excellent puck handler and an excellent decision maker. He makes a great first pass. His Moncton Wildcats team were in the Memorial Cup largely because of his stellar play of defense."

With that in mind, caught up with various TV, print and online personalities concerning those prospects, and some even weigh in with some draft predictions....

"In my mind, the Islanders need at least one franchise defenceman moving forward. We saw in these playoffs what a difference they can make, especially the likes of Pronger and Keith. Assuming Hall and Seguin go first and second, that will leave at least one of Erik Gudbranson, Brandon Gormley or Cam Fowler available on defence. I think Fowler, an excellent skater and puck mover, would be a great fit for the Isles.

If he's developed properly -- likely starting with a return for at least one more year of junior -- then the Islanders will have a 25+ minute defenceman who can move the puck and play against other team's top players. When you look at consistently good teams, you'll find they have a mobile, puck moving defence.

With 6 picks in the top 100, this is a crucial year for the Islanders at the draft."

--Gord Miller, TSN

"In all likelihood, they'll be drafting a defenseman.  And, since word on the street is that Florida is going to take Erik Gudbrandson third, the Isles should (and will) take Cam Fowler if he's available, and if not, Bandon Gormley.  Either way, Isles fans should be excited to add another quality piece to their young core."

-- Justin Bourne, Bourne’s Blog

"(Erik) Gudbranson/(Cam) Fowler. (They can provide) defence that can play sound on the defensive side of the puck, and make plays offensively. Check the Blackhawks Duncan Keith and/or (Brent) Seabrook. Stability starts at the back end."

-- Kevin Weekes, Analyst, CBC’s Hockey Night in Canada & The NHL Network




J. Tavares 82 38 48 5 86
K. Okposo 60 18 33 -8 51
R. Strome 81 17 33 23 50
F. Nielsen 78 14 29 8 43
B. Nelson 82 20 22 6 42
A. Lee 76 25 16 9 41
J. Bailey 70 15 26 3 41
N. Leddy 78 10 27 18 37
J. Boychuk 72 9 26 15 35
T. Hamonic 71 5 28 15 33
J. Halak 38 17 4 .914 2.43
C. Johnson 8 8 1 .889 3.08 is the official Web site of the New York Islanders Hockey Club, L.P. and are trademarks of New York Islanders Hockey Club, L.P.  NHL, the NHL Shield, the word mark and image of the Stanley Cup and NHL Conference logos are registered trademarks of the National Hockey League. All NHL logos and marks and NHL team logos and marks as well as all other proprietary materials depicted herein are the property of the NHL and the respective NHL teams and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of NHL Enterprises, L.P. Copyright © 1999-2015 New York Islanders Hockey Club, L.P. and the National Hockey League. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy |  AdChoices |  Terms of Use |  Contact  Us |  Employment |  Webmaster | Terms of Use